Head coach Paul Maurice didn't divulge the specifics behind Scheifele's benching.
"We have some things that we value as a group," Maurice said postgame, according to The Athletic's Murat Ates. "Mark's a real competitive guy, and that gets the best of him sometimes, I think. We just need to adhere to our core values."
Scheifele ended up logging 17:11 of ice time in the game - his second-lowest total of the season. He was minus-2 with no points in the contest.
Jets captain Blake Wheeler said Scheifele responded well to the benching.
"We need him out there to have success," Wheeler said. "I thought he did a good job with it."
Scheifele leads the Jets with 54 points in 47 games.